Understanding Pennsylvania Child Custody Cases
An explanation of the Child Custody Process by a local Family Law Attorney in Northampton & Lehigh County
Stages of a Child Custody Case in Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania Custody cases typically follow a well-defined path through the local court system to ensure fair resolution. Let's take a closer look at the stages involved in a custody case in Northampton County and Lehigh County:
1. Case Initiation: The process begins when one party files a complaint or petition, seeking court intervention in decisions typically made by parents.
2. Custody Conference: Your case proceeds to a custody conference where a Master or Conference Officer aims to facilitate an agreement between the involved parties. This conference is an informal gathering attended by the parties and their legal representatives.
3. Conference Officer's Role: During the custody conference, the Conference Officer doesn't have the authority to make rulings or decisions. No formal evidence or testimony is presented. Instead, the Master will prepare a report for the judge who will preside over a trial if an agreement isn't reached.
4. Settlement at Custody Conference: In most cases, reaching an agreement at the custody conference stage is advantageous, as it avoids the expenses and stress associated with a custody trial. Many custody cases are resolved during this phase.
5. Pre-Trial Conference: If an agreement isn't reached at the custody conference, the case advances to a Settlement/Pre-Trial Conference with a judge. This stage offers another opportunity for settlement and helps outline the logistics of a potential trial. The nature of the Pre-Trial Conference can vary, involving formal or informal proceedings, the presence of the child(ren), additional paperwork, and limited testimony based on the judge's discretion.
6. Trial: If an agreement remains elusive after both the custody conference and pre-trial conference, the case proceeds to a formal trial. Trials can vary in duration, spanning from a few hours to several days. If your case reaches the trial stage, we will provide detailed guidance on the process, logistics, preparations, and specific methods closer to that time.
Navigating the stages of a custody case requires careful preparation and legal guidance. Our Lehigh Valley Family Law Attorneys are here to assist you every step of the way, with attention to your legal rights and interests.
Pennsylvania Child Custody Factors
Pennsylvania no longer uses the former 16-factor formulation. Under 23 Pa.C.S. § 5328, courts consider all relevant circumstances and 14 listed considerations. The court must give substantial weighted consideration to four safety factors: which party is more likely to ensure the child’s safety; present and past abuse; child-abuse and protective-services information under § 5329.1(a); and violent or assaultive behavior. No single factor controls the result, and the statute limits adverse treatment of circumstances caused by abuse or reasonable protective efforts.
The current statutory considerations address:
Which party is more likely to ensure the child’s safety.
Present and past abuse by a party or household member.
Child-abuse and protective-services information identified in 23 Pa.C.S. § 5329.1(a).
Violent or assaultive behavior by a party.
Cooperation and conflict, including safe continuing contact and reasonable protective efforts that must not be mislabeled as parental alienation.
Each party’s willingness and ability to prioritize the child’s needs, provide appropriate care, and perform parental duties.
Stability and continuity in the child’s education, family life, and community life, subject to necessary safety-related changes.
The child’s sibling and other familial relationships.
The child’s well-reasoned preference, considering developmental stage, maturity, and judgment.
The proximity of the parties’ residences.
Employment schedules, availability to care for the child, and appropriate child-care arrangements.
Drug or alcohol abuse history of a party or household member.
The mental and physical condition of a party or household member.
Any other relevant factor.
The court examines the totality of the circumstances, gives weighted consideration to safety-related factors, and may not treat one factor as automatically dispositive. Circumstances caused by abuse or reasonable efforts to protect a child or abused party may not be weighed adversely as specified in § 5328(a.1).
Standard Provisions in Custody Orders
In custody cases, while each situation is unique, there are several standard provisions that are typically included in custody orders to ensure the well-being of the child:
1. Legal Custody: Legal custody grants the ability to make major decisions for the child, including those related to healthcare, religion, education, and extracurricular activities. In most cases, legal custody is shared between the parents, ensuring that neither parent can make unilateral decisions.
2. Physical Custody: Physical custody determines the periods of time each parent will spend with the child. It's important to note that there is no automatic presumption of a 50/50 or equal custody split in Pennsylvania. Many judges believe that it's often in the child's best interest to spend the majority of their time with one parent rather than a strict 50/50 arrangement.
3. Holiday & Vacation Schedules: Typically, custody orders outline holiday and vacation schedules. Each parent is typically granted 1-2 weeks of vacation with the child(ren) each year, and custody during major holidays alternates throughout the year and from one year to the next.
4. Transportation: Custody orders also address the locations and times for custody exchanges, ensuring a clear plan for transportation.
5. Telephone Contact: In many cases, the court may order daily phone or video contact with each parent to maintain regular communication.
6. Communication & Contact Information: Parents are often required to keep lines of communication open and promptly update the other parent in case of any changes in their contact information.
7. Non-Disparagement: All custody orders include provisions prohibiting either parent from engaging in actions or making statements that may harm the child(ren)'s relationship with the other parent.
8. Relocation: Custody orders commonly restrict either parent from relocating with the child to a new residence if it significantly affects the other parent's ability to spend time with the child(ren).
While these provisions are standard, it's important to remember that custody orders can be customized to fit the specific needs and circumstances of each case. Our legal team is here to ensure that your child custody order aligns with your unique situation and prioritizes your child's best interests.
Less Common Provisions in Pennsylvania Custody Orders
In Lehigh Valley child custody cases, there are less common provisions that may be either requested by one party or ordered by the court. While this list is not exhaustive, it provides examples of such provisions:
1. Right of First Refusal/Preferred Babysitter Rule: The right of first refusal in child custody cases means that one parent must offer the other parent the opportunity to care for the children before seeking the services of a babysitter or another family member. This rule promotes parental involvement and ensures that both parents have the chance to be with their children.
2. Urine Screenings: In cases where there are allegations of drug or alcohol abuse, the court may order one or both parents to undergo random urine screenings for a specified period. These screenings are typically conducted at the parents’ expense, and current pricing should be confirmed with the selected provider. The aim is to address concerns related to substance abuse and ensure the child's safety.
3. Supervised Visitation: If there are concerns that a parent's behavior may pose a risk to the child, the court may order supervised visitation. During supervised visitation, the child spends time with the parent under the supervision of another responsible adult. This supervisor can be another family member or a professional provider. Supervised visitation is usually considered a temporary arrangement until any concerns are resolved and the child's safety is ensured.
These less common provisions are introduced when specific circumstances or concerns necessitate them. It's essential to understand that the court's primary goal is to safeguard the child's best interests, and these provisions are tailored to address unique situations that may arise during custody proceedings.
Other Types of Child Custody Proceedings in Pennsylvania
While the majority of custody cases are resolved without going to trial, it's important to be aware of some less common types of custody proceedings that may arise:
1. Special Relief / Emergency Custody: In exceptional circumstances, the court may hold expedited evidentiary hearings instead of the standard months-long process leading to a full trial. These situations are rare and typically involve an imminent risk of harm to the child(ren). Special relief or emergency custody hearings prioritize the child's immediate safety and well-being.
2. Contempt Proceedings: Contempt petitions can be filed if there are allegations that a parent is not complying with a custody order. Contempt proceedings typically follow a similar path as modification proceedings. The case is initially scheduled for a custody conference, and if an agreement isn't reached during the conference, it proceeds to a judge. If the judge determines that a parent has violated the custody order, they have the authority to take punitive measures to ensure compliance.
3. Relocation Proceedings: All custody orders prohibit a parent from relocating away from the local area with the child(ren). If a parent wishes to move and the other parent does not agree, the relocating parent must seek permission from the court to do so. Relocation proceedings involve a thorough evaluation of the proposed move's impact on the child's well-being and the best interests of the child.
These less common types of custody proceedings are invoked when specific circumstances warrant their consideration. The court's primary concern in each case is the welfare and best interests of the child(ren), ensuring that their safety and stability are maintained.
Looking for a Child Custody Attorney?
Our Easton Family Law Attorneys Can Help.
Lehigh & Northampton County Family Law Staff
Easton Child Custody Attorneys
About This Information
This page addresses Pennsylvania law and common practice in Northampton and Lehigh Counties. Court procedures, deadlines, and available remedies can change and may depend on the facts, the assigned judge, and the governing order. The linked official sources should be checked for later amendments, and advice should be based on the specific matter.